M
| Name | Class Year | Sport |
|---|---|---|
| Chester Massino | Class Year: 1956 | Sport: |
| James Matta | Class Year: 1961 | Sport: Football, Men's Basketball |
| Armond J. Mauzey | Class Year: 1928 | Sport: |
| Greg McBroom | Class Year: 2002 | Sport: Football |
| Ralpheal Eric McClain | Class Year: 1984 | Sport: Football |
| Clay McConkey | Class Year: 2010 | Sport: Baseball |
| Sean McCormick | Class Year: 2005 | Sport: Football |
| Ronald McCready | Class Year: 1961 | Sport: Football, Men's Basketball |
| Tom McGhee | Class Year: 1962 | Sport: Football |
| Jill McGinnis Kern | Class Year: 1995 | Sport: Women's Basketball |
| Tim McGuire | Class Year: 1978 | Sport: Men's Basketball |
| John Royce McIntosh | Class Year: 1981 | Sport: Football |
| Ralph McKinzie | Class Year: 1923 | Sport: Football |
| Amos Isaiah Means | Class Year: 1927 | Sport: |
| 1976-77 Men's Basketball Team | Class Year: | Sport: Men's Basketball |
| 1985-86 Men's Basketball Team | Class Year: 1985-86 | Sport: Men's Basketball |
| 1986-87 Men's Basketball Team | Class Year: 1986-67 | Sport: |
| 1991-92 Men's Basketball Team | Class Year: 1991-92 | Sport: Men's Basketball |
| 1992-93 Men's Basketball Team | Class Year: 1992-93 | Sport: Men's Basketball |
| 1993-94 Men's Basketball Team | Class Year: 1993-94 | Sport: Men's Basketball |
| 2003 Men's Tennis Team | Class Year: 2003 | Sport: Tennis |
| Robert Meredith | Class Year: 1958 | Sport: Men's Basketball |
| Frederick Millard | Class Year: 1949 | Sport: Football, Men's Basketball |
| Walter Miller | Class Year: 1936 | Sport: Men's Basketball |
| Tracy Miller Bennett | Class Year: 1985 | Sport: Track & Field, Volleyball, Women's Basketball |
| Mike Minehan | Class Year: 2012 | Sport: Football, Track & Field |
| Stephanie Mullens Hampton | Class Year: 1996 | Sport: Softball |
| Amy Mulvaney Doman | Class Year: 2002 | Sport: Softball |
| Morgan Murphy | Class Year: 2005 | Sport: Football |
| Fred Mursner | Class Year: 1936 | Sport: |
| Robert Myers | Class Year: 1998 | Sport: Golf |
| Michelle Myers Allen | Class Year: 1997 | Sport: Softball, Women's Basketball |
| Class Year: | Sport: Men's Basketball |